Building a fine art collection is a significant investment that requires careful planning and protection. With artwork valued anywhere from hundreds to millions of dollars, collectors must have the proper insurance in place. However, Insuring Fine Art Collections can seem complex with technical terms and specialized policies.
Contents
Key Terms and Concepts
Before exploring specific policies, it’s important to understand some basic insurance lingo:
Insured Value
This is the maximum amount the insurer will pay out if a covered loss occurs. Make sure the insured value accurately reflects the current fair market value of your entire collection. Underinsuring can leave you vulnerable if a major claim happens.
Deductible
The deductible is the amount you pay out-of-pocket before insurance kicks in. Higher deductibles lower your premiums, while lower deductibles increase costs but provide better protection against small losses.
Premium
Your annual or monthly payment to the insurer for coverage. Premiums are based on factors like insured value, deductible, location/security of your collection, claims history, etc.
Appraisal
A formal written assessment of the fair market value of individual artworks or your entire collection performed by a qualified professional. This provides documentation to support insured values and claims.
Actual Cash Value (ACV)
The depreciated value of the damaged property, usually its purchase price minus wear and tear. Most personal articles are insured for ACV.
Replacement Cost
The cost to repair or replace damaged property without deductions for depreciation. Fine art is usually insured on a replacement value basis.
With basic terms defined, we can now dive into different types of fine-art insurance policies.
Types of Fine Art Insurance Policies
There are various ways to structure insurance for art collections. The two main categories are stand-alone policies versus adding art coverage to your homeowners/renters policy.
Stand-Alone Fine Art Policy
A separate policy exclusively for insuring fine art is ideal if you have significant assets to protect. Benefits include:
- Higher insured limits, sometimes into the millions
- Broader coverage including worldwide transit of artworks
- Specialized appraisal/claims adjusters experienced with fine art
- Potential tax-deductibility of premiums as an investment expense
Homeowners/Renters Policy with Added Art Coverage
If your collection is still growing, bundling art insurance into your existing homeowners/renters plan may suffice temporarily. However, most policies cap art coverage at $25,000-$50,000 and have less favorable terms versus a dedicated art policy. Coverage may also be excluded for certain high-risk items like jewelry.
Special fine art riders or endorsements can sometimes be added to boost limits to the $100,000-$250,000 range. But truly significant collections require a stand-alone policy.
CollectorPlus
A hybrid option is CollectorPlus policies from insurers like Hiscox. They blend homeowners and fine art coverage, offering increased limits of $500,000-1,000,000 specifically for the art. Better suited than basic homeowners but more flexible than a traditional stand-alone policy.
Comparing Coverage Types
Within stand-alone fine art policies, options include:
Wall-to-wall Coverage
Your entire collection is insured as one scheduled item up to the total value listed. Simple but risky if high-value pieces are added/removed regularly.
Itemized Coverage
Individual artworks are precisely described and valued separately on the policy schedule. Changes involve filling in new item info. Best for dynamic collections that are frequently bought/sold.
Blanket Coverage
Covers art as one lump sum without listing items. Easy but lacks documentation of specific pieces. Use for minor assets or as temporary coverage before a full appraisal.
You can also customize coverage for high-risk exposures like transit/shipping, off-premises display/storage, and overseas travel with your collection. A qualified agent can assess your unique needs.
Valuation Methods
Accurately establishing fair market values is crucial, whether scheduling items on a policy or submitting an insurance claim. Common approaches include:
Dealer/Auction Records
Sale prices from your art dealer, auction houses, and databases like artprice.com provide objective documentation of market worth. Use within several years of the current date.
Appraisals by Accredited Experts
Formal written appraisals from certified appraisers following ICA/AIC guidelines are considered definitive proof of value by insurers. Renew every 3-5 years as values fluctuate over time.
Comparable Sales Method
Research recent sales of pieces similar in size, medium, subject, and condition to derive an estimated value. Less rigorous than dealer records or expert appraisals.
Documentation strengthens claims but isn’t always available depending on the piece’s history. Insurers also consider replacement cost, artist credibility, and future appreciation potential. Have valuations reassessed periodically as your collection grows.
Additional Factors to Consider
Location and Security Measures
Properties with advanced alarms and storage take priority versus those barely securing collections. Insist on safety upgrades if requested by underwriters.
Deductible Amount
Aim for a deductible between 1-5% of insured value to avoid overpaying on premiums for dollar-for-dollar protection against tiny losses. Have funds reserved to cover the chosen deductible amount.
Inflation Protection
Opt for automatic inflation clauses increasing coverage by 2-5% yearly to protect values from erosion over multiple policy periods. The extra premium is nominal but worth it.
Disaster Plans
Create an inventory with photos, store receipts, and appraisal records offline. Maintain backups offsite. Consider off-premises storage if hurricanes/floods are a concern at home.
Claims Process
Document damage promptly via photos/videos before discarding debris. Ensure prompt insurer response by following all claims procedures carefully. Stay patient, as adjustments sometimes take time.
FAQs
Here are answers to five common questions fine art collectors have about insurance:
What isn’t covered by a standard fine art policy?
Certain items require special endorsements due to increased risks – photos, stamps/coins, firearms, wine/spirits. Damage from normal wear and tear, gradual deterioration, and restoration work may also be excluded. Read the fine print!
How do I insure the art I plan to sell in the future?
Temporary coverage riders during a consignment/auction allow you to ship works without voiding protection. For art intended for resale, declare the nature of your ownership and intended future disposition upfront to the underwriter.
One small claim likely won’t influence future costs substantially. Repeated losses could, though, be based on developing risk profiles. Promptly addressing any safety issues identified after a payout also curries favor with underwriters.
When should I increase coverage amounts?
Reassess limits annually or whenever your collection value materially exceeds current insurance due to major purchases. Don’t let years lapse between appraisals either to mitigate potential disputes down the line.
Can my collector friend insure pieces borrowed for the exhibition?
Yes, most policies will cover art temporarily loaned or borrowed by named individuals for up to 60 days, assuming full responsibility is transferred. It’s wise for both parties to notify their respective insurers for seamless claims handling if needed.
Conclusion
Proper insurance safeguards your livelihood passion – fine art collecting. With informed choices around coverage types, item documentation, security best practices, and claims preparedness, you’ll have solid protection for both short-term losses and your long-term investment’s appreciation. Still confused? Consult an expert with in-depth knowledge of the nuances of insuring fine art portfolios.
Be the first to comment